WHY CHOOSE US?
VALUE
A local insurance agency helps you save by finding the right discounts and coverage for your needs, with personalized service you can’t get from a 1-800 number.
LOCAL
We offer expert advice, personalized coverage, and real support when you need it. No call centers, just someone who knows you.
SERVICE
As your local agent, we provide hands-on service, quick responses, and real help. You’re never just a policy number. We take the time to understand your needs and are here whenever you need support.
PAYTON GARRETT
OWNER/AGENT
Payton Garrett is a local Farmers® agent and owner of Garrett Family Insurance in Dyer, Indiana. He specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance, helping customers make informed decisions with confidence. Payton takes pride in delivering personalized coverage, dependable service, and knowledgable guidance to protect what matters most.
Payton is a local in Dyer, and loves to connect and service his community!
Give him a call or text at (219) 259-2066 for a personalized insurance review.
GARRETT FAMILY INSURANCE
2005 Hart St.
Dyer, IN 46311
(219) 259- 2066
© 2035 by Name of Site. Created on Wix Studio.
OUR INSURANCE SERVICES
Home Insurance
With this wild weather, having the right home insurance matters. I make the process easy and hassle-free, so you’re protected no matter what comes your way.
Auto Insurance
From highway cruisin’ to backroad adventures, roads can throw anything your way. I make getting auto insurance easy, so you can hit the road with confidence
Life Insurance
Life moves fast, but protecting the ones you love never goes out of style. I’m here to make life insurance simple and meaningful
Commerical Insurance
Running a business means you’re built tough, but even the best need a little backup. I’ve got your commercial insurance covered, so you can focus on what you do best